Tuesday, November 3, 2009

A tour of German horse magazines

A friend loaned me all her horse magazines, and I have been going through them for weeks. At first I had trouble understanding them, but as time passed, I started picking up on the horsey nomenclature of this land. The titles of these magazines, in case you are curious, are Cavallo, Mein Pferd, Pferdboerse, Freizeit Reiter, and Reiter Revue. These are general magazines that do not specialize in jumping or dressage, but have an overall approach.

I thought I would share the things I found odd or interesting. Mostly I wanted to share what I found different from my experiences with American magazines.

I had the idea to do this blog entry when I read one particular article about a riding academy in Hong Kong. They discuss what riding is like there, how they use ex race horses, and it costs about 80 euros an hour for a group lesson, but worse, you have to get on a waiting list because there are so many people who wish to ride, and only a couple riding stables. What stopped me in my tracks was the following line:

"The Chinese know next to nothing about horses."

I read it twice, and then confirmed with my man that that is what it actually said. Whew, talk about Politically Incorrect! I can't imagine reading a sentence like that in an American horse magazine. At that point I got ready for some culture shock. Ready?

Gaiting for better and worse

A much less tortured Tennessee Walking Horse exists in Germany. Loved for their gait and calm nature, the article condemned the American TWH show scene, where horses wear diesel oil and chains to make them step higher. Here in Germany, it looks like they only use weights and high shoes. The average price for a 3 year old saddle trained TWH here is 8,000 Euros (10k$).


The Icelandic is Europe's cause for concern, with their totling tests putting the horses in an upside down position, causing them pain in their backs, so the articles say. They wear weighted shoes too. These magazines are quick to point out what they consider cruelty, and no one's identity is protected.






Looks like he can touch his elbow with his heel as he tolts.










Now I know what inspired the gaping mouthed carousel horses in merry go rounds.










For Shock Value

Every month there is a "Worst Horse Accident" photo of the month contest.





































For debate or scorn

Flash nosebands are sold on every bridle in Germany. I cannot find a normal noseband on any bridle in my catalogs. Yet, they are condemned as cruel in more than one article.









Rollkur is bad! We all agree, but it is good to see the German magazines point the finger at the worst offenders.










Here is Anky, stopping Salinero with all her strength. What a pity, because they should be an example of fine riding at their level. They are scorned here.










Indeed you can buy products that support the cause to end Rollkur. However that works, I am not sure, but at least your product has the Anti-Rollkur logo on it. My friend has an Anti-Drawreins sticker on her car. Really! Germans hardly ever put stickers on their cars.









Cruppers hinder movement, to the extent of doing damage to a horse's back. 5 experts tell you not to use them. My response is, Have you never ridden in the mountains? Also, they only tighten when a horse is descending a very steep slope. Otherwise, they stay loose and they do not hurt a horse's back.







Horsekeeping

What is up with this way of feeding horses? I don't know the english word for it, but this is what we use for cattle, goats and sheep back home. The animalas stick their heads through and UNDER bars to eat. I can only imagine how many facial injuries Baasha would have if our last boarding situation had had one. Horses snark at each other while they eat, and the normal response is to fling their heads away or up. Don't the manufacturers know that?






I read an article about how they cause harm, but in every single issue of every magazine I read, there is a picture ad selling these horse head traps. I am relieved that the editors are trying to educate people about not buying them.





As I have mentioned, all the barns I have visited have concrete stall flooring with no mats. Additionally, they have concrete or cement block paddocks for winter. That is, many many horses in Germany have concrete underfoot 100% of the time in wintertime. I saw lots of pics in the mgazines of stables with this footing.

Just today I looked at the local horse forum, and someone asked about resurfacing her winter paddock, and she was told by several list members to buy concrete blocks.

Here is the type used in paddocks. Someone else posted photos of her stable, with the concrete block system in place.








This is normal here, not the exception.










I see this concrete block footing everywhere here and it really mystifies me. I used to clean this type of paddock three times a week, and woo was that fast and easy! And the horses never had a fleck of dirt on them, because they never lay down.










I have seen stables with these walls, I cannot believe my eyes when I see them. How often do the people have to extricate horses who have rolled though the bars, getting their legs stuck? The articles agree that horses should be able to stick their heads out of their stalls (it is one of the criteria used in judging the riding stables). But in this case, I would worry.

To be continued

13 comments:

Melissa-ParadigmFarms said...

Personally I like it that there seems to be less 'political correctness' in the magazines! I will also go on the record and say I do not mind a propertly adjusted flash noseband. The one they showed in the picture is so tight I don't even know how they got it that tight! I can fit 2-3 fingers in the flash I use on one of my horses. I use it not for tying her mouth shut but because it can help hold the bit very steady in their mouths which she likes.

The hay feeder and the stall front they showed - that just seems to be begging for an injured or dead horse to me, yowzers. I don't like the idea of a horse standing on concrete 24/7 for months at a time but I can see the advantage of having some areas done that way for when the ground is super yucky but you still want the horses to go out.

Funder said...

Fascinating! I'm glad to hear they don't sore TWHs over there. Weighted shoes are pretty bad, but probably no worse than living on concrete or getting rollkur'd. And the poor Icies! :(

lytha said...

Melissa, I agree, a flash noseband is just a dropped noseband plus a regular cavesson. Why it is an object of cruelty, I can only infer that they are used too tightly.

Some concrete areas would be fine, I think so too. But all? All footing is concrete, 6 months a year, with no respite? (They bed their stalls in straw, but there is concrete directly underneath.) Everything I have learned in my American past tells me this is wrong. I know you wouldn't put in concrete under your residents' feet for half the year!

Funder, I am glad they are condescending the American show scene for TWH too. I hope they keep that up! Germany tries to be so cruelty free, printing a number on every egg you buy, indicating whether the hen was in a cage or not.....and it is illegal to dock a dog's tail. And a horse's apparently, from the Shire exhibit I saw last month.

You're right, at least there is no soring so far.

Happily, people realize here that horses are "wander" animals, who need to be out walking about and not trapped in stalls. So when people complain to the authorities about a horse with a snow buildup on his back (rememeber what I said about there being no such thing as "your own business" here?) .......they are slowly won over to the idea that horses should be outside, because of the lengthy signage at farms telling the public so. It is a good thing, now they just need to make the footing kinder.

Reddunappy said...

Wow the difference is culture is amazing! Do you still get your American magazines?

AareneX said...

Hmmm, concrete. I agree that continual concrete is sub-optimal.

However, I'm pleased to see that the *outdoor* concrete is semi-permeable--it lets rain water go into the soil, but keeps the horses' feet from churning the surface to mud. That is actually good soil management, even if it's not ideal horse management. I'd like to see them migrate to something like this:
http://www.turtleplastics.com/catalogs/pdfs/Hoof-Turf.pdf
(the open-grid) which is a grid tile made of plastic that serves the same purpose as the open-tile concrete blocks but is easier on horse feet. You can drive a dump truck on the plastic tile without breaking it, but it has some "flex" which I think makes a better footing surface for horses.

I had to look up "Rollkur." Clearly, I need to read more magazines!

lytha said...

Reddunappy, I only get Equus, but I LOVE IT!! I have to pay extra to get them to send it here, but I am so happy they do!

Aarene, I looked at that ad for those grids, I noticed how they do not advertise that they are suitable for lining entire paddocks (winter). Are they, though? I would think so. Anything softer than concrete is cool, in my book.

Those concrete grids they have here let the urine flow thru, and the rain, being good soil management, as you said, but the holes are so small, no hoof can find relief from the hardness.

Aarene, you told us about your geotile experiment years ago, with gravel overlay, and it was appropriate so we went ahead with the idea, and got several hundred grids. They are a little bit too slippery right now, because the holes are not filled in with grass yet. I hope when they do fill in, Baasha is more comfortable walking on them.

However, I would not expect him to live on those grids all the time, they are hard. They are just for walkways and barn/fence borders.

Rachel said...

I need to be honest here... my overall feeling of seeing those pictures and advertisements is one of just dismay for poor horses that are injured or misused in any situation. Wow... and I'm so glad for less political-correctness when it comes to keeping our four-legged friends comfortable and safe!

Laughing Orca Ranch said...

That last photo: What are the keeping in there? Tigers?

I giggled when you said that horses 'snark' at one another when eating. That's a perfect analogy, Lytha.

~Lisa

ps I replied to your question over at my blog.

Fantastyk Voyager said...

Thanks for the very interesting post! What a shame to see such a rider as Anky Van Grusven yanking on her horse like that!

Nuzzling Muzzles said...

All good points. I worry about keeping my metal railing round pen in the horse paddock, because I've seen the horses roll and get their legs caught in it. Fortunately, they've all become pros at extricating themselves delicately.

Unknown said...

There are those merry go round models.

Darn. I was hoping they had gone extinct.

We have concrete floors at home and have to use stress mats to wash dishes and cook. Poor horses!

lytha said...

Rachel, exactly. Something I have come to learn to expect in the blogging world, but not in magazines. That is why I was so surprised at all the un-censored faces of people yanking on horses, and names and addresses and web addresses of stables which should be avoided.

Lisa, I wish I could talk to the owners of facilities with the "Tiger Cages" and ask about the rate of accidents. Perhaps they are safer than they look.

FV, Thank you. If this is normal in American magazines and I am just out of it, let me know. I admit I only read Equus!

NM, I would think that horizontal bars are safer for horses than vertical. I have also rescued horses who have cast themselves in their stalls, so even solid walls can capture a horse.

Breathe, I am glad you agree with me cuz I wonder if I am some sort of footing fanatic, or just...American and shocked at the differences here.

Tara said...

Some of that is flat out crazy, lol....
And Thanks for the info, :) I am looking forward to being in WA... I get really sick of all the negative crap people say... I like to make the most of my time living places!
I wish I could make another 3 year tour in Germany happen..lol Though no way would I be able to bring the two horses with us...
Tara