This is part 2 of my reaction to the stack of German horse magazines I was given. I was surprised by so many things, I had to write about it.
Libel?
Every issue of a major riding magazine had a "Riding Stable Test" where an undercover agent from the editor would book a riding lesson at an unsuspecting stable in Germany. Since there are literally thousands of riding stables in Germany, three stables are reviewed per month. They begin the article with a picture of the facility, and the facility name, address, telephone, and website. And then they proceed to bash the heck out of the facility. What? That's allowed? I couldn't help feeling sorry for the unsuspecting barn owners. Their farms are judged on how much mud is present (this is where the concrete floored paddocks are applauded), how dark the barn is, if turnout is available, whether the stalls were cleaned that day, and the condition of the arena. I liked how they said horses must be able to stick their heads out of their stalls, or else the barn loses points.
They list the name the riding instructor, and criticize his style and effectiveness in giving an advanced rider a lesson. This is good, but I had the feeling none of these instructors knew they were being tested, and that their names would appear in the next issue.
(I learned that all riding instructors must be certified here.)
The reviewer snaps photos at every chance, revealing inadequate to illegal conditions. Exposing abuse is a good thing, but I was surprised to see this happen so sneakily, every month in a riding magazine.
Illegal would be the stable one undercover rider visited, and she found horses in standing stalls. That is, horses who live tied up. There is a sign on the wall, "These horses are learning to be trailered." But a boarder told her, "No, they live there." (Standing stalls are illegal in most German states.)
I concede that a new rider coming in for a lesson must be shown your facility in the best possible way, stalls should be clean, and the riding instructor should have had his coffee. Some of those lessons were horrible to witness. I am a little worried about finding a good riding instructor here. The magazine has stables which get good reviews, but most were scary. That riding instructor certificate program needs improvement!
Slaughter or Euthanasia?
Here in Germany, when a horse is ill or old, the horse owner must decide whether to slaughter or euthanize. Seriously! This is a two way system here. That is why my vet asked me if my horse was intended for food or not when he vaccinated my horse. Agh, excuse me? But so it is, here. I do believe there are still knackers who will come and shoot your horse and take it away for meat, but I learned through the magazines that many horses travel to Poland or wherever in trucks, to be slaughtered there. From what I have read, it sounds like a lot of horses whose owners chose euthanasia did not get the sedation shot first, and had a horrible death. Previously I thought all euthanasia was done with the sedation!
Less Prudish
Europeans are less shy about body parts, we all know that, but I was not prepared for how many working body parts I would see in these magazines, scenes I have never witnessed in an American 'zine.
This article was about testicles, and I believe the title, "Eiertanz" is a pun, calling stallion parts, "eggs." Every month I read a horse health and behavior magazine from America (Equus). Equus has these horse parts too, but they are not discussed using puns.
I am finally accustomed to seeing advertisements with topless women, but I didn't expect to see it in a horse magazine. Wait a minute...no body parts here. This must be their conservative ad.
Conformation Opinions
In the magazines I read back home, there were often conformation clinics, where an expert pointed out flaws in a horse's build. In this popular riding magazine, several experts give their opinions about a horse, but they all conflict. Almost every expert has something to say about the size of the horse's mouth. One out of 4 experts noted a horse with tied in knees.
I was happy to see one of the 4 also noted this one's posty hind legs. Am I just too leg oriented?
No one pointd out the calf knee on this one. This is a calf knee, right? They often note if the horse has a long or short back, and what training is in order for these horses to compensate. That is good. (Check out the box drawn around this horse...it doesn't touch the start and end of the body of the horse, oops.)
Forum Questions
Each month a forum question is given, and I found a couple interesting.
1.) Do you feed supplements during shedding season? (Shedding season is a time where horses need extra immune system support, according to what I have learned here.)
Answers: Yes, yeast. Yes, flax. Yes, Malzbier. (This is like liquid vegemite and rootbeer mixed. Horses seem to like it.)
2.) Is it too dangerous to let horses stay outside at night? (Really?)
Answers: No, No, and Yes. (Should I be worried about something? We have a padlock on our gate, and a motion detector light over our barn, but is that enough?)
T Posts
New, from America! T Posts, guaranteed to have more longevity than wood. Every single magazine had a T Posts ad, each one pictured capped for safety, touting ease of installation and durability. I love it. T Posts come to Germany. Incidentally, we got ours from a German firm, an authentic American replica!
A new device
This thing is a training device to teach a rider to have softer hands. It breaks under pressure, giving you an audible and physical fail.
Kind of a neat idea.
Western Riding Everywhere
I am getting used to seeing western saddles, chaps, hats, and reining and cutting all on Quarter Horses in magazines, the newest coolest thing. And the cute (really, adorable) thing is, they all try to use English terms for riding. I hear a lot of western riding stables give lessons completely in English. That I have to see!
Also, Parelli and Monty Roberts are huge here.
They name a lot of reining maneuvers correctly, and some, not.
BTW, does anyone say "Whoa" to stop a horse? I mean, phonetically? I am only a West Coast girl, I don't know, but we all seem to say "Ho."
Do you know what they say to stop a horse in Germany? It's not a word at all, it's a sound with the tongue, that sounds like Brrrr. Hm. I just thought of something. How do you exactly shout that sound? You know, when your horse was told to Stand, say at one end of a roundpen, and he thinks about moving. We normally yell HO and he stops that thought. I wonder what they say here as a correction?
I would love to hear about horse magazines in other countries, anyone?
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
9 comments:
Cultural differences are so weird, no? But fun to learn about too! I don't mind barn/trainer exposes to help the horses, but it sounds like they take it a bit far. Loved the idea of stallion "eggs"!
In the UK it would only be libel if what they wrote was untrue.
Cultural differences...wow. Too dangerous to keep a horse out at night??
Not sure I like that gadget to improve hands..
Is is too dangerous to keep a horse out at night . . . wow I'm thinking if they did an undercover visit to my farm they would see horse abuse everywhere!
Lytha, this is all so fascinating!
Undercover agents, ha! I wonder what Fugly would do with that....hmmm...
Horses outside at night, uh-oh, here come the undercover agents to Haiku Farm, ready to expose my abuse. Eeek. Are the writers thinking that horses might be stolen? Or that the evil darkness is somehow unhealthy? When I was a kid, an instructor told me that you absolutely couldn't ride horses at night because it was too dangerous....which might come as a huge surprise to endurance riders!
The gadget that breaks...does it leave the rider with no reins attached at all? Seems to me that a heavy-headed horse could learn to break that sucker.
The sound to stop my horse is "ho." However, when I used to get sore after an endurance ride on a particular gelding who shall go unnamed, it was my "whoa-dammit" mucles that hurt.
This is great stuff, keep it coming!!!
I want the job of the riding lesson critic, especially if the magazine pays for the riding lessons. It's not much different from what restaurant critics do, although many of them are famous and recognizable by the restaurant managers. I'd hate to be a riding instructor who is having a bad day when the undercover critic arrives, but at the same time a professional should always provide his best instruction to every student every day. On the other hand, an instructor who is used to working with beginners will probably struggle to work with an advanced rider for the first time. Every rider has to be assessed before the lessons can really begin.
It would be great if the equestrian press in Britain would start to be critical.
To start with, test a number of farriers each month. A fair proportion deserve to be slated for poor work. More criticism might lead to fewer long toes and collapsed heels.
Then I'd aim at DIY barns, there are some horrors around.
Riding instructors, well poor marks for answering phone calls when teaching, and indeed for teaching very little so that clients learn slowly and have to book lots of lessons if they want to advance very far.
As for riding schools, well the barn where I keep my horse has clean stalls, very little mud, a light interior to the barn, horses can put their heads out, tack room is tidy, etc - the manager and staff do a good job, but really these things ought not to be hard to achieve at any decent barn. But, shock horror, some horses are out at night! I must warn the manager immediately.....
Back in Transylvania, the command to a horse to stop was a kind of "prrrr" that only local seemed able to make - like it was bred into the village children. Oddly, the command to back up was the German word "zuruck" (in a country with a Latin language!)
I'm a "whoa girl".....always have been. My good friend says "HO", and I always tell her that it isn't nice to call her horse that name. Ha ha!!!
Kate, I wonder when I will stop noticing cultural differences?
c2b, I wonder what your magazines are like.
Melissa, I wonder what dangers they are talking about!
Aarene, It was more like reading Shame in the Horse Show Ring or Fugly than a magazine.
That gadget has a chain as a back up. I'm glad you enjoyed the post about magazines!
Hey, what is your novel about?
NM, You are right, there was no assessment period, so these things are kind of set up to fail.
WHP, I would love to see your magazines too! Answering the phone during a lesson? NO way! I had a vet answer the phone 4 times once during a 15 minute visit, I was pissed and never had him out again. So in Transylvania they do that tongue thin too, cool. Can they do it loud to stop a horse from a distance?
Lulu, REALLY? You are the first person I've met who says the actual whoa word! I just put a poll up on my blog to see if you are the only person. I remember as a child hearing people say HO and thinking "how odd!" and "how rude" but oops, I grew up to do it too. And I call soda "pop"!
Interesting post, Lytha.
I say whoa, but without the 'a' sound at the end. But if I remove the 'a' it sounds like who, the sound an owl makes. lol!
~Lisa
Post a Comment